| Year | Individual Category | Player | Record |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2012 | Most Yards Rushing - Career | Weston Kenney | 3,447 Yds |
| 2012 | Most Yards Rushing - Season | Weston Kenney | 2,419 Yds |
| 2012 | Most Yards Rushing - Game | Weston Kenney | 399 Yds |
| 2008 | Most Yards Rushing - Quarterback | Nathan Maxwell | 810 Yds |
| 2012 | Most Rushing Touchdowns - Career | Weston Kenney | 47 Tds |
| 2012 | Most Rushing Touchdowns - Season | Weston Kenney | 36 Tds |
| 2012 | Most Rushing Touchdowns - Game | Weston Kenney | 7 Tds |
| 2013 | Longest Run from Scrimmage | Nick Reineger | 97 Tds |
| 2013 | Most Yards Passing - Career | David Irons | 3,729 Yds |
| 2011 | Most Yards Passing - Season | David Irons | 1,159 Yds |
| 2007 | Most Yards Passing - Game | Myles Curtis | 187 Yds |
| 2012 | Longest Pass from Scrimmage | David Irons | 97 Yds |
| 2013 | Most Passing Touchdowns - Career | David Irons | 78 Tds |
| 2010 | Most Passing Touchdowns - Season | David Irons | 25 Tds |
| 2011 | Most Passing Touchdowns - Game | David Irons | 5 Tds |
| 2005 | Best Passing Percentage - Career | Daniel Reed | 60% |
| 2011 | Most Yards Receiving - Career | James Kenney | 1,586 Yds |
| 2010 | Most Yards Receiving - Season | James Kenney | 717 Yds |
| 2010 | Most Yards Receiving - Game | James Kenney | 210 Yds |
| 2010 | Most Touchdowns Receiving - Career | James Kenney | 32 Tds |
| 2010 | Most Touchdowns Receiving - Season | James Kenney | 17 Tds |
| 06-10 | Most Touchdowns Receiving - Game | James Kenney Caleb Maxwell |
4 Tds |
| 2008 | Most All-Purpose Yards - Season | Matt Haynes | 2,652 Yds |
| 2008 | Most Kick-Off Returns Yards - Season | Matt Haynes | 868 Yds |
| 2009 | Most Extra-Point Kicks - Season | Ryan Cate | 10 Pts |
| 2006 | Most Yards Punting - Season | Justin Henson | 517 Yds |
| 2009 | Most Recovered On-Side Kicks - Game | Ryan Cate (K) | 4 |
| 2009 | Most Solo Tackles - Career | Nathan Maxwell | 196 |
| 2010 | Most Solo Tackles - Season | James Kenney | 64 |
| 2009 | Most Sacks - Career | Nathan Maxwell | 21 |
| 2008 | Most Sacks - Season | Nathan Maxwell | 12.5 |
| 2005 | Most Interceptions - Career | Michael Curtis | 7 |
| 2005 | Most Interceptions - Season | Michael Curtis | 7 |
| 05-08 | Most Interceptions - Game | Curtis, Bennett Shorey, Guard |
2 |
| 10-11 | Most Interceptions - Game | Martinez, Martinez James Kenney |
2 |
| 2007 | Most Interceptions Returns for TDs | Stephen Shorey | 2 |
| 2007 | Most Yards Interception Return | Stephen Shorey | 104 Yds |